Glossary term
Top Hat Plan
A top hat plan is an unfunded nonqualified deferred compensation plan maintained for a select group of management or highly compensated employees.
Updated
Read time
What Is a Top Hat Plan?
A top hat plan is an unfunded nonqualified deferred compensation plan maintained primarily for a select group of management or highly compensated employees. It is often used to provide executive retirement or deferred compensation benefits outside the broad qualified retirement plan system.
The term matters because top hat plans are not ordinary 401(k) or pension plans. They have different ERISA treatment, different tax timing issues, and different employee-risk tradeoffs.
Key Takeaways
- A top hat plan is generally limited to a select management or highly compensated group.
- It is typically unfunded and nonqualified.
- Benefits may be subject to employer-credit risk.
- Tax timing and payment rules often depend on nonqualified deferred compensation rules.
How a Top Hat Plan Works
The employer promises a deferred compensation or supplemental retirement benefit to eligible executives. The plan may track a notional account, formula, bonus deferral, or supplemental benefit. Unlike a qualified plan, it is not designed for broad employee participation and does not receive the same package of qualification rules and protections.
Feature | Top hat plan treatment |
|---|---|
Eligibility | Limited to a select management or highly compensated group. |
Funding | Usually unfunded for tax and ERISA purposes. |
Benefit security | Participant may rely on employer’s future ability to pay. |
Reporting | Plan administrators may file a top hat statement with the Department of Labor. |
Employee Risk
Top hat benefits can be valuable, but they usually do not sit in the same protected account structure as qualified retirement plan assets. If the promise is unsecured, the executive may be a general creditor of the employer. That distinction becomes important if the employer has financial trouble.
Executives sometimes focus on the headline benefit amount and miss the funding question. A promised benefit can look similar to a retirement account on a statement while carrying a very different claim against the employer.
The employee should also read payment timing, separation-from-service rules, change-in-control provisions, vesting language, and tax consequences carefully. A small drafting detail can change when the money is paid or whether it is forfeited.
How It Differs From a Broad Retirement Plan
A 401(k) plan is designed for broad employee participation and follows qualified plan rules. A top hat plan is selective and usually exists to supplement compensation for executives whose income or benefits exceed qualified plan limits. It is closer to nonqualified deferred compensation than to a mass-market retirement account.
That selectivity is part of the definition. If a plan is broadly available to rank-and-file employees, it is usually not being described as a top hat plan, even if the benefit is generous.
The Bottom Line
A top hat plan is a selective executive deferred compensation arrangement. It can provide meaningful supplemental retirement income, but the participant needs to understand the plan’s unsecured nature, payment timing, tax treatment, and employer-credit risk.